Are you confused what type storage to choose for new or old Computer, HDD or SSD (Solid-State-Drive)? SSD storage is being popular in these days. Many computer users prefer to buy SSD instead of HDD (Hard Disk Drive). Here we will analyse speed performance of both (Hard Disk Drive and Solid-State-Drive). This guide will help you finding which is best for your needs, what is best and my final verdict.
Read/Write Speed of HDD
Seagate® Desktop HDD
Seagate Laptop Ultrathin HDD
Hard Disk Drives are most popular storage because HDD is cheapest mass storage device, there is no other efficient device available in market, so it is best. Here we will analyse speed of Read/Write of Hard disk. A Hard Disk can transfer data at max 140MB/s, However HDD data speed depends on disk RPM as 5400 RPM HDD write data at speed of 77 and 76MB per second and 7200 RPM HDD write at speed of 100 and 98MB. It is slower when multiple read/write done as it takes time (latency or Seek time) to move head on data sectors. Below is screenshot of Hitachi HDD showing 65Mb/s read and 48MB/s Write speed.
HDD read write speed test on @5400 RPM HDD
Read/Write Speed of SSD
Segate 1200 SSD
Samsung SSD 840 Pro
SSD speed on Macbook PRO late 2013, it showing read speed of 655MB/s and write speed of 729MB/s.
SSD has more performance in read/write speed. Above screenshot showing read speed of up to 655MB/s and write up to 729 MB/s on macbook pro 250GB SSD. It is amazing speed 5-6 times more than HDD speed. In this speed 250GB data transfer will take max 390 seconds (Approx. 7 Minutes). This test is performed on SSD to SSD data transfer because HDD max read speed is 140MB/s which is 3-4 times lower than SSD write speed. Same 250GB data transferring to HDD will take 35-40 minutes or more . So final conclusion is that SSD wins in read/write speed and far ahead from HDD.
Note: SSD speed may be lower by manufacture, see manufacture details if you looking to buy.
SSD vs HDD
SSD is faster than HDD, when i boot computer over SSD it takes max 20 seconds to boot. But in same i use only HDD it takes 30-40 seconds time to boot system. SSD takes a few milliseconds to ready on startup because it has no mechanical components to prepare. HDD has mechanical components to startup so it takes time on start up.
SSD Power Consumption is half to a third instead of HDD, SSD don’t have mechanical parts. The lowest-power HDD (1.8-inch size) can use as little as 0.35 watts, 2.5-inch drives use 2 to 5 watts and 3.5-inch drives can use 20 watts. Hard disk power consumption is higher than SSD. However DRAM SSDs uses similar power as HDD and requires to be connected to power after system shutdown.
SSD costs higher as US $0.45/GB which is too high in comparison of HDD cost US $0.05 per GB to $0.10 per GB. So HDD is cheaper rather than SSD. However SSD cost going slightly down as SSD cost was US $0.59 in April 2013 now it is $0.45 GB. Price is different of SSD’s according to their performance and manufacture.
No Defragmentation needed for SSD as it has low latency (Seek time) but Hard Disk Drive requires disk defragmentation for optimal response time to access data.
SSDs has 500GB common and maximum 2TB storage capacity which are too expansive and still rarely available. If you needed more than 2TB( 2TB SSD is too expansive), it will best option to choose HDD (SSDs available up to 2TB but too costly).
No noise with SSDs but HDDs do noise as they use mechanical parts.
Data on SSD is more secure rather than HDD, SSD is newer technology it has one disadvantage, it costs higher than hard drives.
Durability
SSD contains NAND cells so it have limited cycles of read/write but don’t worry you can read/write approx 250GB data per day on a 250GB SSD for 10 years (Read manufacture specifications of SSD for more about this). It limits writing cycles so that no loss of data, it is as safe as HDD.
Conclusion
In my opinion SSDs are too good to use if budget doesn’t matter for you. SSD increases read/write performance of computer. Hence computer programs loads 3x faster than HDD. For example – Loading Adobe Photoshop components from Hard Drives takes time, shows loading components but when i open it on SSD loads faster. If budget don’t matter go for it. If you have any questions you can ask me in comments.
[ssba]
I am confused by some of the talk that is flying around about the SSD versus HDD.
We all know what the HDD can do and the speeds it can access with as long as the drive is not full of fragmented files, file degradation and infected with virals, bots and other infectoids that take up space and processor time when running in the back ground.
But the SSD is not the SuperDrive of the computer world.
I agree, the SSD has a fast ACCESS SPEED when accessing a large group of small files, and the HDD is not far behind in access speed. But what has been forgotten is the HDD is a fast reading device and on a single large file, where access and location is at a minimum, its speeds move right on up there.
Then, what most are telling people is the SSD will increase the computers speed. Sorry, after either the SSD or HDD load the RAM, the processor runs at the same speed. This part is generally lost in the conversation when referencing the SSD.
Write wear is another concern with the amount of write hits the memory can stand decreasing by a large amount of numbers, and now I learn that the SSD drive can have more memory failures as the drive ages. Lest we forget, another article I read claims that the SSD can also have control program failures, adding to the list of concerns.
The more I learn about this memory drive, the more I wonder why it is being used by the average computer user. Speed is actually a non issue, the memory is on a constant course of being hit with write wear and you cannot use the entire amount of memory on the memory drive because the access speed slows down drastically. (term borrowed from another article.)
The SSD does not have good long term memory archive numbers in years for retention of memory, and always the fear the memory will lose the data either from time sitting on the shelf or the room temperature or combination of both.
It seems the SSD is perfect for the commercial market where constant reading of drives for data would be perfect for it, however it still will have the age and failure concern that any other user has. But for someone to knowingly purchase a SSD with known memory that will begin to decay the day you start to write to it, and have additional memory problems as it ages, seems unusual.